Tuft And Paw Really Great Cat Litter Review (I Tested It Out To Be Sure)

Tuft + Paw makes low-tracking, virtually dust-free litter made from soy by-products. The company's Really Great Cat Litter checks many boxes for quality cat litter, but is it as great as it sounds?

Tara Maurer holding cat smiling

Last Updated: April 25, 2024 | 6 min read

Cat sitting on top of a litter box with Tuft and Paw litter bag next to it.

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

The variety of litter options on the market never ceases to amaze me. It’s not that I’m surprised by the amount of suppliers. It’s actually the ingenuity of these manufacturers to make even the most unlikely materials into a litter box substrate that interests me.

Perusing the pet store aisles, you’ll see traditional options like clay, pine, and silica. But you’ll also see unique options, including walnut, corn, coconut, and Diatomaceous Earth. The latest litter on the market? It’s a material you’d never expect: tofu.

When cat furniture company Tuft + Paw released its Really Great Cat Litter, I was surprised to see it’s made from soybean fiber. I’ve tried many cat litters with my girls, Luna and Lucy—many of which fall short. There’s really nothing worse than walking barefoot in your house only to collect loose litter on your feet. So, when Tuft + Paw says its cat litter doesn’t track, I eagerly looked into the product.

Is Tuft + Paw cat litter really non-tracking? And does this litter hit the other must-haves for cat litter (high-absorbancy, low dust, easy cleaning, etc.)? The short answer is yes, this cat litter is a fantastic option, even for picky cats. Our Tuft + Paw cat litter review covers everything you need to know, including pricing, performance, pros, and cons. I even tested it out with my cats to see if it lives up to its name.

6 Key Features

  1. Litter made from soybean fiber (Tuft + Paw is our top pick for tofu cat litter.)
  2. Ultra low-tracking pellets
  3. Minimal dust
  4. High absorbency for clumping and odor control
  5. 100% flushable
  6. Biodegradable and compostable

Brand History

Tuft + Paw bag with cat using litter box.
I like that Tuft + Paw’s Really Great Cat Litter is lightweight. I can carry and pour the bag easily.

Tuft + Paw began in 2016 as a high-end cat furniture company with the mission of providing thoughtfully designed, high-quality products to cat lovers. Using designers, engineers, and cat behaviorists, the brand created durable, feline-friendly pieces that complement modern decor.

Tuft + Paw felt like a breath of fresh air for cat owners who were disappointed with the selections in the pet store aisles. Some of its products, like the Cloud Nine window hammock, Stellar cat bed, and Cove litter box, were instant hits for their aesthetically pleasing design.

Tuft + Paw has expanded its selection to include cat litter, toys, blankets, and more. The company designs each piece with functionality, safety, and aesthetics in mind.

Tuft + Paw Cat Litter Review

Tuft + Paw Really Great Cat Litter Review

Tuft + Paw Really Great Cat Litter
  • Ingredients: soybean fiber, corn starch, corn flour, guar gum, charcoal
  • Subscription service (free shipping)
  • $29/9.5 lb. bag = $3.05/lb.
  • Low tracking and low dust
  • Activated charcoal for odor control
  • Unscented

Tuft + Paw makes its Really Great Cat Litter from five ingredients: soybean fiber, cornstarch, guar gum, and charcoal. The formula is non-toxic and free from synthetic fragrances that can be too much for a cat’s nose. Instead, Tuft + Paws adds charcoal to its formula, which absorbs moisture and traps odors in and around the litter box. (While it may be tempting to pick a scented litter, cats want to be able to identify their scent, and heavily perfumed litters may drive them away from the box.)

But let’s take a step back. Why tofu? The main selling points that Tuft + Paw makes for its litter is that it’s low-tracking, virtually dust-free, and 100% flushable for easy clean-up. Tofu pellets are larger, making them less likely to stick to your feline’s paws or fur. Unlike conventional cat litter, tofu litter is also very low in dust. It’s a great option for cats and humans since dust can cause respiratory issues in both cats and humans over time.

Tuft + Paw overhead shot of litter bag open.
My cats seemed to enjoy the texture of this litter, even choosing it over their typical option.

The fact that Tuft + Paw’s litter is flushable isn’t a huge selling point for me. Many septic systems aren’t compatible with flushable litter, even if advertised as such. That being said, tofu litter’s high absorbency makes it suitable for clumping and odor control.

Another perk of tofu litter is the nice paw-feel. This feature is essential for two reasons. First, your cat won’t use the box if they don’t like the substrate. Second, soft textures feel much more comfortable, especially for cats that have been declawed.

Is Tuft + Paw Cat Litter Good?

So, tofu litter sounds like a great option, but how does Tuft + Paw perform? Despite the pellets being lightweight, the product does a great job of not tracking. Users praise this litter for being low-tracking and low dust. If this is your main concern, Tuft + Paw is a win.

The litter is also super high absorbency and clumps exceptionally well. Some users complain that it clumped too well and was difficult to remove from the box. But if you’re looking for an excellent clumping option, Really Good Cat Litter performs well.

Some users report a lack of odor control, so keep this in mind. I clean my litter box multiple times daily, but the lack of odor control could be a significant deal-breaker if you can’t.

My Personal Experience Testing Tuft + Paw Cat Litter

Tuft + Paw overhead shot of bin with litter in it.
I filled the litter box about two inches deep with litter and placed the box next to their typical option.

Tuft + Paw sent me a sample of its Really Great Cat Litter to try with my cats, Luna and Lucy. As with any cat litter, Tuft + Paw recommends switching to its cat litter slowly. 

Changing litter can be stressful for cats, so rather than switching to a new litter all at once, you’re encouraged to gradually incorporate new litter by mixing it with the old one. One the first week, start with an 80/20 ratio, the next week try 60/40, and gradually increase until you’re exclusively using the new litter.

Tuft + Paw in a litter box and cat looking at it.
The girls were very interested in the tofu litter and used it right away.

I did not take this approach with my felines. Instead, I kept their current litter box (which uses pine pellets) and placed a new litter box filled with Really Great Cat Litter next to the old box. This way, they could use either box at their discretion. Plus, I could determine if they were interested in the new tofu litter without changing their old pine option.

The first thing I noticed when pouring this tofu litter was that I didn’t need to turn my head, cover my nose, and wait for the dust to settle. As someone with asthma, I really appreciate that this litter isn’t irritating my respiratory system. The litter has a very light natural scent that was a pleasant change from my typical litter.

Tuft + Paw bag of litter next to litter box.
Lucy chose Tuft + Paw’s Really Great Cat Litter over her typical pine pellet option.

I was happy to discover that my cats took to Tuft + Paw’s litter right away, even choosing it over their old option. They were instantly curious about the new litter and used it the day I put it out. Thankfully, neither cat tried to eat the litter, which I had read was an issue for some users.

Tuft + Paw is true to its word—its litter doesn’t track. This is huge. I have never used a litter where my cats didn’t track it at least a few feet. My cat, Luna, is a kicker and always sends particles flying. With Really Great Cat Litter, I have not noticed a single piece on the floor. 

I typically clean the litter box twice daily and had no problems cleaning the box with Tuft + Paw. The litter absorbed the urine into an easily scoopable clump. None of it stuck to the walls or bottom of the litter box.

Tuft + Paw litter scooped up.
Here, you can see how well Tuft + Paw litter clumps together. I easily scooped the clumps without any mess.

I haven’t noticed any unpleasant odors since using this litter. Overall, I am incredibly pleased with Tuft + Paw litter. 

Tuft + Paw Subscription Plans

To purchase Tuft + Paw Really Great Cat Litter, you must sign up for a subscription. Choose to receive shipments every month or every three months. Products ship the same day and typically arrive within 2-5 business days. Shipping is free on all Really Great Cat Litter subscriptions. Tuft + Paw lets you cancel your subscription at any time.

A litter bag should last approximately one month if you have one cat. Tuft + Paw recommends buying one bag per cat monthly. See more cat litter subscription options.

Supply Cost
1-month supply (1 bag every month)$29
3-month supply (3 bags every 3 months)$79

Pros & Cons

Low-tracking and minimal dustExpensive
Excellent clumpingSubscription only
Eco-friendly pelletsSusceptible to mold if not stored properly (this applies to all tofu cat litters)
Activated charcoal for odor controlPellet size does not work with automatic litter boxes
Free of synthetic fragrances, artificial colors, and toxic ingredientsMade in China (country with the highest CO2 emissions), so it doesn’t have a good carbon footprint
Soft on the pawsCats may try to eat it
30-day money-back guarantee
Free shipping

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some frequently asked questions about Tuft + Paw cat litter. Don’t see yours? Ask us in the comments.

Is Tuft + Paw Worth It?

Tuft + Paw is pricey, but it’s worth a try if you have the budget. The formula is cat-safe and eco-friendly. Buying this product will ensure you do not sweep up litter particles daily.

Is Tuft + Paw Really Flushable?

This litter disintegrates in water, allowing you to scoop and flush cat waste. That being said, not all septic systems support flushable litter, and some local and state municipalities prohibit the flushing of pet waste because it can pollute the waterways. Before flushing, check with your local and state regulations.

Comparing Tofu Cat Litter

If you found our Tuft + Paw litter review first, you might be curious how it compares to other tofu litters on the market. View our top three picks for the best tofu cat litter.

Why Trust Love Your Cat?

Tara has 25 years of experience with cats and spends countless hours researching and testing to provide in-depth detail on her topics. She currently lives with two nine-year-old domestic felines, Luna and Lucy, who like to make a mess of their litter box space. She’s constantly testing new litters to find the best on the market.

Stainless steel litter box on the floor.

Author's Suggestion

Best Stainless Steel Litter Box

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top